Old Memories

Sometimes They Are Like A Flood

Tonight, I learned something that should not have taken me this many decades to understand.

It started with a horse.

Not even a big story. Just a memory. I found out that years ago, when I bought my first horse, Gram was furious. Enraged, I was told. That detail slid into my chest and lodged there. Because horses had been her dream once. She had many. I bought one.

And suddenly I was asking a question I have never let myself ask out loud:

Was she jealous of me?
Did she hate me?

Once that door cracked open, everything else came rushing in behind it.

The art school.

I was fourteen. I loved to draw. I sent away for one of those art tests you see advertised on television. I filled it out, mailed it in, and forgot about it. Until a man from a prestigious art college in the Twin Cities came to see me. He called first but Gram shut him down. Instead of accepting her answer, he came to visit me. He didn’t just compliment my work. He wanted me. He said they would make sure I completed my high school courses. He believed in me.

She said no.

Too dangerous. Too far. Too young. And besides, I wasn’t good enough.

I remember those words far more clearly than I remember the man’s face.

There were other moments like that. A farmhouse on twenty acres that I could have turned into a home and a shop and a place for my horses. Too much money, she said. Not practical. Later, someone else bought it, split it up, made a huge profit. I watched that opportunity pass and felt something I couldn’t name at the time.

Every time I reached forward, something pushed me back.

Every time I found something that felt like mine, there was a reason it shouldn’t be.

And yet, she could also be my biggest emotional supporter. But those moments were rare. And they had to be earned.

Tonight I finally said the sentence that unlocked everything.

She required compliance in order to give love.

The moment I said it, something inside me went quiet.

It wasn’t hate.

It wasn’t that she didn’t love me at all.

It was that love came with conditions.

Love when I agreed.
Love when I stayed close.
Love when I did not outgrow.
Love when I did not outshine.
Love when I did not leave.

When I distanced myself years ago because all she did was criticize me, I still helped her. I mowed the yard. I fixed what needed fixing. I just left when she arrived. I didn’t understand then that I was protecting myself. I only knew I couldn’t keep absorbing the constant message that everything wrong in the world was somehow my fault. And I was so tired of being a pawn in a game I had no control over.

After a few years, I let her back in. Slowly. Carefully. She reeled me in again. I wanted it to be different.

Then everything fell apart.

The lies. The dismissal. Her believing others over me.

I have been fighting for her. Protecting her. Trying to save what is left. And at the same time, grieving the fact that the woman who raised me is already gone, even though she is still alive.

Tonight I asked a question that scared me.

Did she hate me because she hated my mother?

And the answer I received was not what I expected.

It wasn’t, “Yes, she hated you.”

It was this. Maybe she struggled with your independence. Maybe she felt safest when you were compliant. Maybe your growth felt like loss of control.

And then came the question that broke me open.

If she had loved you without conditions, if she had been proud without control, if she had chosen you freely… would you still be protecting her right now?

Before I even finished reading the words, I said yes. Out loud. Alone in my house.

Yes.

Then I read the rest, and the tears came so hard I couldn’t stop them.

Because for the first time in my life, I understood something so simple and so devastating.

I was never the problem.

Not when I wanted to go to art school.
Not when I bought a horse.
Not when I dreamed bigger.
Not when I spoke up.
Not when I refused to comply.

I was not too much.
I was not ungrateful.
I was not disloyal.

I was becoming my own person.

And for someone who tied love to control, that was threatening.

That realization did not make me angry.

It made me free.

I can love her and still acknowledge that she was not a good mother.

I can protect her without sacrificing myself to her.

I can grieve her while she is still breathing.

And I can finally stop carrying the belief that I was somehow unworthy of joy.

If you are reading this and you have spent your life trying to earn love that only comes when you shrink yourself, please hear me.

Your independence is not betrayal.
Your ambition is not cruelty.
Your joy is not an attack.

Sometimes the people who raised us love us the only way they know how. And sometimes the way they know how is tangled in fear and control and insecurity.

That does not mean you were hard to love.

Tonight, I realized I would have protected her even if she had loved me well.

That tells me everything I need to know about my heart.

And for the first time, I am no longer asking whether I deserved better.

I know I did.

Go Fund Me